EU reaches deal on fund for Ukraine
By Matina Stevis Gridneff and Monika Pronczuk
BRUSSELS — After weeks of standoff, European Union leaders brought Prime Minister Viktor Orban of Hungary on board and agreed Thursday (Feb 1) to create a 50-billion-euro ($54.1 billion) fund for Ukraine, providing a critical lifeline to a country at risk of financial meltdown in the midst of war with Russia.
The breakthrough was an especially significant one for both Ukraine and the EU. For Ukraine, which desperately needs the money to keep basic services running, it offered stability and assurance as US aid is held up in Congress.
For the EU, it demonstrated European resolve to stand united in support of Ukraine against Russia, even if the United States wobbles, as well as a determination to bring an often obstructionist Orban to heel.
Small as his country is, the Hungarian leader has made himself a big antagonist against EU rules and norms, drawing both rebukes and monetary punishments from his partners. Orban has also been an outsized obstacle to many of Europe’s ambitions, including some sanctions against Russia and even Sweden’s bid to join the NATO alliance.
He has repeatedly used the EU requirement for unanimity to push Brussels for concessions, including the unfreezing of money that has been withheld to prod him to make democratic reforms.
Before Thursday’s meeting, Orban had been demanding an annual chance to veto the disbursement of money to Ukraine, which is to be dispensed in the form of loans and grants over the next four years. But that demand was rejected. Instead, leaders agreed to a regular review of the way the money was being spent to assuage concerns about diversion or corruption, EU officials said.
Under the agreement reached Thursday, the European Commission, the EU executive arm, will draft an annual report on how the Ukraine fund is being used. European leaders will have a chance to debate its performance and raise any concerns about it.
The European Parliament needs to approve the fund by simple majority, a bar that should be easily cleared, and the vote could take place as early as this month.
It appeared that Orban did not receive anything material in exchange for giving up his veto for the fund, valued at about $54 billion.
“All 27 leaders agreed on an additional €50 billion support package for Ukraine within the EU budget,” the president of the European Council, Charles Michel, said on social media just an hour into Thursday’s meeting. “This locks in steadfast, long-term, predictable funding,” he added. “EU is taking leadership & responsibility in support for Ukraine; we know what is at stake.”
Talks had been gridlocked, and the mood toward Orban, the closest ally in the EU of Russian President Vladimir Putin, had been souring since Orban blocked the first attempt to introduce the fund for Ukraine in December.
Orban’s long-term obstruction of the EU’s support of Ukraine has been riling his European partners. He has held up or watered down support for Ukraine, including some sanctions against Russia, since the war began.
The Hungarian leader, who appears to relish his spoiler role, has claimed that his resistance comes down to a fundamental disagreement with other European leaders: He does not believe Russia poses a security threat to Europe, nor does he think the EU should be throwing its weight behind Ukraine.
But Orban regularly uses his levers within the bloc — often his ability to veto decisions that require unanimity, such as the introduction of the Ukraine fund — to push for funds that he has lost access to over a long-standing dispute with the commission over his domestic policies.
The EU and Hungary have long clashed over policies on the rule of law, corruption and minority rights.
The commission has taken Hungary to task over, among other issues, the hijacking of judicial appointments, which it says interferes with the courts’ independence; laws that discriminate against LGBTQ+ people; and the defanging of anti-corruption authorities.
The commission has blocked Hungary from gaining access to some 20 billion euros until it can demonstrate that it has altered those policies to bring them in line with EU rules and values.
If Orban’s demand for an annual veto for the Ukraine fund was a play to get access to more funding, it failed.
Officials on Thursday said he had only managed to extract a vague reference in the joint conclusions that leaders would issue at the end of their summit Thursday. That reference would urge the European Commission to be “proportionate” in the way it froze funding for member states it punishes for violations, as is the case with Hungary.
The swift decision Thursday was welcomed with relief by some EU leaders weary of the endless fights with Orban and eager to avoid another showdown that would harm the appearance of unity toward Ukraine.
Shortly after the agreement was announced, Prime Minister Mark Rutte of the Netherlands wrote on social media: “I’m delighted that we have reached agreement on support for Ukraine. This 50 billion euro package will help us achieve more structure, transparency and predictability in our financial aid to Ukraine.”
The message was clear, he added: “Ukraine can count on our support, both now and in the future.”
The news was warmly welcomed in Ukraine.
“It is very important that the decision was made by all 27 leaders, which once again proves strong EU unity,” President Volodymyr Zelenskyy of Ukraine wrote on social media. “Continued EU financial support for Ukraine will strengthen long-term economic and financial stability, which is no less important than military assistance and sanctions pressure on Russia.”
-New York Times
Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.